Judge keeps land-return claim alive in Saugeen Ojibway Nation's Bruce Peninsula case
An Ontario Superior Court judge has dismissed Canada's bid to rule out the return of 651 Crown-owned parcels on the Bruce Peninsula before the remedies phase of the Saugeen Ojibway Nation's treaty case.
By David Ellis · Published · Updated · 2 min read

The Saugeen Ojibway Nation can keep pursuing the return of Crown-owned land on the Bruce Peninsula in its long-running treaty case, after an Ontario Superior Court judge dismissed a motion by Canada to take that remedy off the table.
Justice Wendy Matheson released the decision, Saugeen First Nation v. The Attorney General of Canada, 2026 ONSC 5969, on Nov. 10. It was reported locally this week by the Owen Sound Sun Times and the Owen Sound Current.
The ruling does not award any land or money. It means the First Nations' claim to 651 parcels owned by Canada or Ontario will go ahead to the remedies phase of the lawsuit, along with their claim for $90 billion in compensation and damages. According to the decision, Canada owns 184 of the parcels and Ontario owns the rest. Privately held land is not part of the claim.
The Saugeen Ojibway Nation, made up of Saugeen First Nation and the Chippewas of Nawash Unceded First Nation, is asking the court to declare it the beneficial owner of the parcels through a constructive trust. Canada, supported by Ontario, argued that remedy is not available for the breaches the court found.
Matheson ruled that Canada had not met the high bar for a preliminary motion, which required it to show the claim was plain and obvious to fail. "I cannot rule out the possibility, however small, that the Phase 2 evidence may displace the conclusion I would otherwise draw, granting this motion," she wrote, as quoted by both outlets.
She also wrote that there are "compelling arguments in favour of the position that the claim for land will be unsuccessful," and that a partial unwinding of Treaty 72 is not an appropriate remedy, the Current reported.
In the first phase of the case, decided in 2021, the court found the Crown failed to act diligently on its 1836 Treaty 45½ promise to protect the peninsula from settler encroachment. The Ontario Court of Appeal upheld that finding in 2023.
No costs were ordered on the motion. The Current reported that Saugeen and Nawash are preparing a joint statement.
Sources: Ontario Superior Court decision 2026 ONSC 5969 (Nov. 10, 2026), as reported by the Owen Sound Sun Times and the Owen Sound Current (Nov. 17, 2026).
Send us a tip, or tell us what to cover
Know something we missed, or want a story followed up? Tell us. Email is optional; add it only if you'd like a reply. For anything longer, use the full tip form.
Get The Banner free by email.
Local Chatsworth news, events and road updates in your inbox. Free, and you can unsubscribe anytime.


